Helo a chroeso i
Blog Rhuthun/Ruthin Blog

cyhoeddwyd gan Non Liquet, cydweithwyr a’u tîm

Great Idea. Poor Deilvery

The town council has sponsored three 'community books of you' designed to gather memories of Ruthin castle, Ysgol Borthyn and retail shops in Ruthin. They've been produced by a local company. They will be officially launched later this afternoon. Meanwhile, we've taken a look at them online and while the principle is great, the output isn't. There's such potential but it hasn't been tapped.

Ruthin Castle: blurry image and sloppy editing (to the right of the picture, a white gap) is not untypical

What’s disappointing about these 'books of you'?
  • The lack of detail on most pages. You get the feeling that the people who've done this have just taken information when available rather than properly researched it.  
  • The fact that the pictures are relatively low resolution, which means when you enlarge them you miss the detail. 
  • There are few anecdotes. Some, admittedly, but few.
  • There are no approximate dates for many of the pictures. You're left guessing as to when they were taken.
  • Few people in the photographs are named.
  • The whole project is somewhat limiting and limited.
Though we hate to say so, this is one project that would have been better, simpler, cheaper, easier to collate and much more accessible via people's comments on Facebook. 

But we still hope the launch tomorrow is a success.


Previous Post Next Post